David Johnston’s 55-page report on foreign interference in Canada’s democratic institutions released on Tuesday sounds as if it could have been written by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who appointed him to the job.
Johnston’s report exonerates the Trudeau government from allegations it failed to act on foreign interference for partisan reasons, based on confidential discussions he had with the PM, his cabinet ministers and government officials, the details of which he says he can’t discuss publicly for reasons of national security.
As a result of this conclusion, Johnston said there is no need for a public inquiry — even though when Trudeau gave him the job of being his “independent special rapporteur” on foreign interference on March 15, he believed one would be necessary.
Instead, Johnston said he will preside over public hearings on foreign interference and that he doesn’t need the power to subpoena documents or have witnesses testify under oath.
KINSELLA: What the decision to forego Chinese interference inquiry fails to do
GUNTER: Johnston sings ‘Sound of Silence’ on China
While stating his mandate didn’t include addressing media leaks about foreign interference, Johnston’s report goes on to criticize every one of the media leaks and the leaker or leakers, saying they led to unfounded speculation critical of the government.
Bizarrely, Johnston simultaneously asserts in his report that foreign interference by China is a growing threat to Canadian democracy, that current government measures to combat it are inadequate and that “absent the leaks, I would not have been appointed to undertake my work.”
So, Johnston’s pretzel logic is that inaccurate leaks about foreign interference reported by the media, led to his investigation of foreign interference, which found serious problems with how our government addresses foreign interference, that don’t need to be addressed by a public inquiry.
He said combatting foreign interference should be the work of Parliament, ignoring the fact that as an unelected friend of the prime minister, appointed by the PM, he has rejected the will of the House of Commons, which voted in favour of calling a public inquiry.
While Johnston played down his friendship with Trudeau during his media conference releasing his report — even though Trudeau has described Johnston as a long-time family friend — it’s difficult to understand how he could possibly believe that his report or its conclusions will satisfy public concerns about foreign interference in our democracy.
Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. We ask you to keep your comments relevant and respectful. We have enabled email notifications—you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.
Join the Conversation